Animal Behavior Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 500 words

Animal Behavior - Essay Example mental attack.† The tentative conclusion and the statement that the authors’ ideas are likely to change with time, does not actually make the suggestion convincing. The authors, however, present a wide spectrum of thoughts on the issue and describe several experiments that relate to the concept. The manner in which the arguments are presented need to be considered and their objectivity assessed, to make the overall argument worth consideration. The authors seem to have made several sweeping assumptions in order to narrow down the scope of the discussion. Thus they have been able to offer the reader a wide spectrum of ideas to ponder upon. An example would be the statement that most neuroscientists do not attempt to study consciousness either because it is a philosophical problem or because such study is premature. Discarding the philosophical aspects of the issue, the article goes on to argue that such study is not premature. No valid reasons are given for discarding the philosophical aspects, even as there is no dispute about the need to study the issue scientifically in the present time. I don’t think the issue can be approached purely from a scientific perspective without considering the philosophical aspects. The article dwells on several features and forms of consciousness and introduces the concept of â€Å"neuronal correlates of consciousness† or NCC. The force of the argument is substantially reduced by asserting that the assumptions are â€Å"tentative† and that â€Å"personal decisions† were taken to set aside several topics without further discussion. Further it goes on to state that a precise definition of consciousness was premature and that it was â€Å"not profitable† to make certain arguments. Such statements in a scientific, or at the very least an objective discussion, dilute its validity. However, visual consciousness, its uses, nature, characteristics and biological explanations etc, discussed in the works by others in the field are used,